August 29, 2005

The Orginialism Myth

I have stated before, that the concept of originalism is marketing a best, that when you actually get down to the question of how our modern government would operate under the ‘original’ intent of the constitution.

My Constitutional Law professor, tonight, gave a great example of the folly of originalism. Women presidents. If you go by a strict interpretation of the Constitution, and intent of the framers, women are not allowed to hold either office.

From Article 2:

The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America. He shall hold his Office during the Term of four Years, and, together with the Vice-President chosen for the same Term, be elected, as follow...(Emphasis mine)

The constitution clearly states the president should be a man. And, since when the constitution was written, they intended that women could not hold office, under a strict originalist view, women can never be president of the united states.

Some might argue that the suffrage amendment changed this, but that amendment is clearly limited to the rights of women to vote, not hold office.

Comments:
Posted by Henry at 07:03 PM || Link to me || Track this post (0) || Category:: Law, Just Left On